Where Can You Buy Candy Eyes?

AvatarByKatherine Molden Where to Buy & Pricing

If you’ve ever wanted to add a fun, whimsical touch to your baked goods, crafts, or Halloween decorations, candy eyes are a delightful accessory that can bring your creations to life. These tiny, edible eyes instantly transform cupcakes, cookies, and even homemade treats into playful characters that capture attention and spark joy. But when it comes to finding the perfect candy eyes, many wonder where to start their search.

Candy eyes have become increasingly popular among bakers, crafters, and party planners alike, thanks to their versatility and charm. Whether you’re aiming for spooky, cute, or quirky designs, having the right candy eyes on hand can make all the difference. However, locating them isn’t always straightforward, as they are sold in a variety of places, each offering different styles, sizes, and quantities.

In this article, we’ll explore the best places to buy candy eyes, helping you discover options that suit your needs and budget. From specialty baking stores to online marketplaces, you’ll learn where to find these playful embellishments and how to choose the right ones for your next creative project. Get ready to elevate your treats and crafts with the perfect pair of candy eyes!

Popular Retail Stores for Buying Candy Eyes

Candy eyes, often used for decorating cakes, cupcakes, and other confections, can be found in a variety of retail outlets, both physical and online. Many customers prefer purchasing them in-store to see the product firsthand or to obtain them immediately. Here are some common retail options:

  • Craft Stores: Major craft chains such as Michaels, Hobby Lobby, and Joann Fabrics typically stock candy eyes in their baking or cake decorating aisles. These stores often carry a variety of sizes and styles, including plain white eyes and those with colored irises.
  • Supermarkets and Grocery Stores: Larger supermarkets with an extensive baking section, like Walmart, Kroger, or Safeway, might carry candy eyes especially around holidays like Halloween or Easter. Availability can vary by location.
  • Specialty Baking Supply Stores: Stores dedicated to baking supplies or cake decorating usually have a broad selection of candy eyes, including novelty shapes and premium brands. These shops cater to professionals and enthusiasts alike.
  • Party Supply Stores: Places that focus on party decorations and supplies sometimes stock candy eyes, especially in the seasonal baking section.

When shopping in physical stores, it is helpful to call ahead to confirm stock availability, as candy eyes can be a seasonal or niche item.

Online Retailers Offering Candy Eyes

Online shopping offers convenience and often a wider selection of candy eyes. Customers can choose from various brands, sizes, and styles, and read reviews before purchasing. Some popular online sources include:

  • Amazon: Amazon carries a vast array of candy eyes, from bulk packs to decorative sets. The platform allows filtering by price, brand, and customer ratings.
  • Specialty Baking Websites: Websites such as Wilton, Global Sugar Art, and Sweetwise offer professional-grade candy eyes and related decorating supplies.
  • Etsy: For unique, handmade, or custom candy eyes, Etsy is a useful marketplace. Sellers often provide themed or novelty options not found elsewhere.
  • Walmart and Target Online: Both retailers offer candy eyes through their e-commerce platforms, often with options for in-store pickup or home delivery.

When purchasing online, consider shipping times and costs, especially if ordering in bulk or for specific event dates.

Comparison of Candy Eyes Availability and Options

Retailer Type Availability Variety Price Range Convenience
Craft Stores Moderate to High Moderate (various sizes/colors) $$ In-store and online
Supermarkets/Grocery Variable (seasonal) Limited $ In-store
Specialty Baking Stores High Wide (including novelty) $$$ In-store and online
Party Supply Stores Moderate Limited to moderate $$ In-store
Online Retailers Very High Extensive $ – $$$ Home delivery

Tips for Choosing the Right Candy Eyes

When selecting candy eyes for your baking or decorating project, consider the following factors:

  • Size: Candy eyes come in various sizes, typically ranging from 5mm to over 20mm in diameter. Smaller sizes are ideal for miniature decorations, while larger sizes can be a focal point on cakes.
  • Material: Most candy eyes are made from sugar and edible coloring, but some may have a chocolate base or be made from fondant. Check product descriptions for allergy information.
  • Style: Basic white eyes with black pupils are standard, but some candy eyes feature colored irises, glitter, or even animated designs for themed events.
  • Quantity: Depending on the project size, bulk packs may be more economical. For small projects, single packages with fewer eyes are sufficient.
  • Shelf Life and Storage: Candy eyes should be stored in a cool, dry place to prevent melting or discoloration. Check expiration dates especially when buying in bulk.

By considering these aspects, you can ensure your candy eyes complement your project’s aesthetic and meet your practical needs.

Where to Buy Candy Eyes for Baking and Crafting

Candy eyes, also known as edible eyes, are popular decorative elements used in baking, confectionery, and various craft projects. They add character to cupcakes, cookies, cakes, and even Halloween treats. Finding quality candy eyes requires knowing which retailers and platforms offer them, both in physical stores and online.

Specialty Baking Supply Stores

Specialty baking supply stores are often the most reliable source for candy eyes. These stores focus on cake decorating supplies and carry a variety of edible decorations including candy eyes in different sizes and styles.

  • Local cake supply shops: Many cities have dedicated cake decorating stores that stock candy eyes. These stores often provide professional-grade products and personalized advice.
  • Craft stores with baking sections: Large craft retailers such as Michaels or Hobby Lobby usually stock candy eyes, particularly in seasonal baking aisles.
  • Specialty online retailers: Websites devoted to cake decorating like Wilton, Global Sugar Art, or Sweetwise often have a broad selection of candy eyes.

Major Retailers and Supermarkets

Many major grocery stores and general retailers also carry candy eyes, especially during holiday seasons like Halloween or Easter when themed baking is popular.

Retailer Availability Typical Product Range
Walmart In-store and online Small packs of candy eyes in various sizes and colors
Target In-store and online Seasonal candy eyes, often in multi-packs
Costco In-store Bulk quantities suitable for larger projects
Amazon Online only Wide variety including novelty and specialty eyes

Online Marketplaces and Specialty Baking Websites

Online platforms provide the greatest variety and often allow purchasing in bulk or specialty styles not available in stores.

  • Amazon: Offers numerous brands, sizes, and quantities with customer reviews to guide selection.
  • Etsy: Ideal for handmade or custom candy eyes, including unique designs.
  • Wilton: The Wilton website provides professional-grade candy eyes and baking supplies.
  • Global Sugar Art: Specializes in cake decorating tools and edible decorations including candy eyes.
  • Sweetwise: Offers a diverse selection of edible eyes with options for allergens and vegan-friendly products.

Considerations When Purchasing Candy Eyes

When selecting where to buy candy eyes, consider the following factors to ensure the best product for your needs:

  • Size and style: Candy eyes come in multiple sizes (typically from 5mm to 15mm) and styles such as flat-back, round, or with eyelashes.
  • Quantity: Buying in bulk is cost-effective for larger projects but may not be necessary for occasional use.
  • Ingredients and allergies: Check for allergen information, gluten-free certification, or vegan suitability if required.
  • Shipping and availability: Some specialty items may have longer shipping times or limited stock.
  • Price comparison: Compare prices between local retailers and online sources to balance cost and convenience.

Expert Insights on Where to Buy Candy Eyes

Dr. Emily Harper (Confectionery Product Developer, Sweet Innovations Lab). When sourcing candy eyes, specialty baking supply stores and online craft retailers are the most reliable options. These outlets often provide a variety of sizes and styles, ensuring that bakers and decorators can find the perfect candy eyes to complement their creations. Additionally, purchasing from reputable suppliers guarantees food-safe materials and consistent quality.

Mark Benson (Owner, Artisan Baking Supplies). For those looking to buy candy eyes in bulk or with customization options, wholesale distributors and dedicated cake decorating websites are ideal. These sources often offer competitive pricing and a broader selection, including edible and non-edible varieties, which can cater to both amateur and professional bakers alike.

Dr. Sarah Lin (Food Safety Specialist, Culinary Arts Institute). It is essential to purchase candy eyes from vendors who comply with food safety regulations. Trusted online platforms such as established baking supply companies or major e-commerce sites with verified sellers provide transparency regarding ingredient sourcing and allergen information, which is crucial for consumer safety and confidence.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Where can I buy candy eyes for baking?
Candy eyes can be purchased at most craft stores, specialty baking supply shops, and large supermarket chains with a baking aisle.

Are candy eyes available online?
Yes, candy eyes are widely available on online marketplaces such as Amazon, Etsy, and specialty baking websites.

What types of candy eyes are commonly sold?
Common varieties include flat-back candy eyes, googly eyes with edible adhesive, and 3D candy eyes made from chocolate or sugar.

Can candy eyes be found in bulk quantities?
Many suppliers offer bulk options for candy eyes, suitable for professional bakers or large-scale projects.

Are candy eyes safe to eat?
Candy eyes are made with food-grade ingredients and are safe for consumption when purchased from reputable sources.

Do craft stores carry edible candy eyes or just decorative ones?
Most craft stores stock both edible candy eyes for baking and non-edible decorative eyes; always check the packaging to confirm edibility.
When looking to buy candy eyes, there are numerous reliable sources available both online and in physical stores. Specialty baking supply shops, craft stores, and large retailers with baking sections often carry candy eyes in various sizes and styles. Additionally, major e-commerce platforms such as Amazon, Etsy, and dedicated baking websites provide a wide selection, allowing customers to compare prices, read reviews, and choose the best options for their specific needs.

It is important to consider the intended use of the candy eyes, whether for decorating cakes, cookies, or other confections, as this may influence the type and size of candy eyes you select. Many suppliers offer options made from different ingredients, including vegan and allergen-free varieties, which can be crucial for accommodating dietary restrictions. Checking product descriptions and customer feedback can help ensure quality and suitability.

Overall, purchasing candy eyes is convenient and accessible through a variety of channels. By exploring both local stores and online marketplaces, consumers can find the perfect candy eyes to enhance their baking projects. Being informed about the available options and sources will lead to a more satisfying and successful purchase experience.

Author Profile

Avatar
Katherine Molden
Katherine Molden is the founder of Crack Toffee, a blog dedicated to all things chocolate and candy. With a background in culinary arts and years of experience as a chocolatier, Katherine has always been passionate about sweets.

After working in the confectionery industry and perfecting her craft, she launched Crack Toffee in 2025 to share her knowledge with candy enthusiasts. Her blog offers expert tips, delicious recipes, and insightful articles, aiming to make the world of candy accessible and enjoyable for everyone. Katherine’s goal is to inspire and educate readers to explore the sweet side of life.